How to Attract Motivated Sellers: Marketing Tactics That Work

Get More Leads. Close More Deals. Start Today for Free.

The difference between struggling investors and those closing deal after deal? They know how to attract motivated sellers before their competition does.

These sellers aren’t casually browsing Zillow. They’re dealing with inherited properties, foreclosure, divorce, relocation, or are simply tired of being landlords.

When your marketing shows up at the right time, you win the deal. When it doesn’t, they’re calling another investor.

Key Takeaways

  • Motivated sellers don’t list on the MLS. You need the right digital marketing strategies to reach them.
  • A strong online presence (website, SEO, and social media) builds trust and gets sellers to call you first.
  • Paid ads like Google PPC give you immediate visibility with high-intent sellers searching “sell my house fast.”
  • Consistency, follow-up, and systems like Vestor CRM turn one-time campaigns into repeatable lead pipelines.
  • Focus on building scalable marketing systems so deals keep coming without relying on luck.

Table Of Contents:

What is a Motivated Seller?

Motivated sellers are not your average homeowners casually considering a move. A motivated seller needs to sell quickly and is willing to be flexible on price or terms to make it happen.

Here are some common situations that often lead to a motivated seller:

  • Vacant Properties: An empty house is a drain on resources and can quickly deteriorate.
  • Accidental Landlords: Trying to sell but stuck renting? These owners are often eager to cut their losses.
  • Properties in Disrepair: Major repairs can be a huge hurdle for traditional buyers.
  • Job Relocation: A quick move often necessitates a quick sale.
  • Facing Foreclosure: Time is running out, and options are limited.
  • Health Concerns: Maintaining a property can become overwhelming.

Your goal is to find these opportunities consistently. The marketing strategies you employ will either make or break you, so choosing the right approach is key.

1. Build a Strong Online Presence

Your website is your digital storefront. For many sellers, it’s their first impression of your business.

What works:

  • Professional design & messaging – Position yourself as a legitimate, trustworthy buyer.
  • Multiple contact options – Phone, live chat, text. Sellers won’t wait.
  • Local SEO optimization – Rank for “sell my house fast [city].”
  • Trust builders – Testimonials, photos, your story, proof you close deals.
  • Mobile-friendly – Most sellers will find you on their phone.

This is exactly why Vestor websites go live in 15 minutes. They’re SEO-ready, conversion-focused, and built to capture motivated seller leads.

2. Leverage Social Media

When sellers research you (and they will), they’ll check your social profiles. Show that you’re active and reliable:

  • Facebook – Community groups, market updates, and helpful content.
  • Instagram – Before/after rehabs, seller testimonials, video walk-throughs.
  • LinkedIn – Build connections with attorneys, agents, and other professionals.

Consistency beats perfection. Social reinforces your credibility and makes your PPC and SEO campaigns perform better.

2. Leverage Social Media

3. Direct Mail (Still Works, But With Digital Follow-Up)

While most marketing is focused online, direct mail remains highly effective, especially when paired with digital marketing.

  • Target pre-foreclosures, absentee owners, and probate lists.
  • Use a multi-touch sequence (6–12 months).
  • Track responses and integrate with your CRM.

With Vestor CRM, every mail response triggers an automated 12-month follow-up sequence, so you don’t lose deals that need time.

3. Direct Mail (still Works—but With Digital Follow Up)

4. Run a Referral Program

Referrals are one of the most cost-effective ways to find motivated sellers, because they come pre-qualified through trust. A structured referral program turns one-time transactions into a steady flow of opportunities.

How to set up an effective referral program:

  • Decide on Incentives: Cash rewards ($500–$1,500 per closed deal) are common, but you can also offer tiered rewards (smaller payouts for leads, bigger payouts for closed deals).
  • Target the Right Sources:
    • Past sellers who had a smooth experience with you.
    • Contractors and service providers who see distressed homes daily.
    • Neighbors of your projects, who often know about other struggling homeowners.
    • Attorneys and agents with clients who need to sell quickly.
  • Make Referrals Simple: Provide cards, a landing page, or even a dedicated phone/text number for referral submissions. The easier the process, the more referrals you’ll get.
  • Follow Up Promptly: Keep your referrers updated on the status of the deal and pay immediately when it closes. Trust fuels long-term success.

With Vestor CRM, you can create automated pipelines specifically for referrals. Every referral enters a pre-built follow-up sequence, ensuring no lead falls through the cracks.

5. Direct Outreach

Direct outreach is about going straight to property owners instead of waiting for them to find you. It requires effort, but when paired with the right systems, it can deliver some of the highest-quality motivated seller leads.

Driving for Dollars

  • Identify Properties – Look for overgrown yards, boarded-up windows, or signs of vacancy.
  • Document Efficiently – Use apps that pull owner info automatically instead of writing it down.
  • Follow Up Digitally – Don’t just mail once. Enter the property owner’s info into your CRM and launch a multi-touch campaign (mail, text, email).
  • Repeat Routes – Drive the same neighborhoods consistently. Problems you didn’t see last month may be visible now.

Cold Calling

  • Get Accurate Data – Skip tracing lists from sources like PropStream. Bad data wastes time.
  • Keep It Conversational – Use natural scripts: “Hi, I’m a local real estate investor—would you be open to an offer on your property?”
  • Call During Prime Hours – Evenings and weekends typically have higher answer rates.
  • Systemize Follow-Up – Add each contact to your CRM and assign reminders for future check-ins.
Cold Calling

Expired & FSBO Listings

  • Expired Listings – Contact owners right after a listing fails. They’re frustrated and often open to investor offers.
  • FSBO Properties – Reach out a few weeks after listing, once they realize selling isn’t as easy as they thought.
  • Position Your Value – Focus on quick closes, no repairs, and cash offers.

The key with outreach isn’t one touch. It’s the consistent, multi-channel follow-up. That’s where Vestor CRM’s automated 12-month nurture campaigns give you the edge.

6. Search Through Public Records

Public records are one of the most overlooked sources of motivated seller leads. They reveal homeowners under financial or personal stress long before they hit the MLS.

Where to look:

  • Foreclosure Filings (NOD/Lis Pendens) – Early foreclosure stages where sellers still have time to act.
  • Tax Delinquencies – Owners behind on property taxes may need fast solutions.
  • Probate Filings – Heirs often want to liquidate inherited properties quickly.
  • Divorce Records – Homes involved in divorce settlements often need to sell fast.
  • Code Violations – Properties flagged for safety or maintenance issues can signal owners who want out.

How to use this data effectively:

  • Move Quickly – The sooner you contact a homeowner after a filing, the better your chances.
  • Use Multi-Touch Marketing – Send letters, follow with calls/texts, and retarget online when possible.
  • Be Empathetic – These sellers are often dealing with difficult situations. Lead with solutions, not pressure.
  • Track ROI – Record which record types produce the best leads so you can focus your efforts.

Vestor helps by integrating these leads into smart digital campaigns. Upload your lists into the CRM, and every homeowner automatically enters a proven 12-month follow-up workflow.

7. Pay-Per-Click Advertising (Immediate Seller Leads)

PPC puts you in front of sellers exactly when they’re searching “sell my house fast.”

  • Target high-intent keywords like “cash home buyers [city].”
  • Send traffic to conversion-optimized landing pages.
  • Track every lead down to the deal.

Vestor manages Google & Facebook PPC for investors nationwide, optimizing campaigns for ROI, not just clicks.

8. Develop Strategic Partnerships

Strategic partnerships are a scalable way to generate warm leads without direct advertising spend. By aligning with businesses that already interact with potential sellers, you position yourself as the go-to solution.

High-value partnership opportunities:

  • Property Management Companies – They work with landlords tired of tenants, repairs, or vacancies. Offer referral fees for introductions.
  • Estate Sale Companies – Families liquidating belongings often need to sell the house, too. Position yourself as the “one-stop” solution.
  • Senior Living Facilities & Elder Care Attorneys – Families moving relatives into assisted living frequently need to sell the home quickly to pay for care.
  • Local Realtors & Professionals – Build relationships with agents who encounter distressed sellers, attorneys handling probate/divorce, and contractors spotting properties in disrepair.

Making partnerships work:

  • Start with Value – Show how referring you makes them look good to their clients.
  • Educate, Don’t Sell – Frame your service as solving their clients’ problems.
  • Pay Promptly – Referrals only continue if people know they’ll be compensated without hassle.
  • Stay Top-of-Mind – Regular updates, thank-yous, and ongoing communication build loyalty.

With Vestor CRM, you can create partner-specific pipelines to track referrals, calculate payouts, and automate thank-you messages, making your partnerships run like a professional business system.

From Tactics to Systems

It’s not about trying every marketing strategy at once. It’s about building a repeatable lead generation system.

  • Pick three tactics to start.
  • Track results and double down on what works.
  • Use tools like Vestor’s customizable CRM and websites to automate lead capture, follow-up, and deal management.

The investors who win aren’t the ones with the biggest budgets. They’re the ones with the best systems.

Final Word

Finding motivated sellers online is about having the right mix of strategies running together. PPC drives immediate leads. SEO and content build long-term authority. Video and reviews establish trust. And CRMs with automation turn clicks into contracts.

Vestor™ systems have generated over $150M for our REI clients since 2015. Whether you need Google or Facebook PPC, a new website, a new or better CRM, or a stronger social media presence, put our lead generation, lead management, and brand-building tools and services to work in your business today.

Start Here for Free

Categories:

Tags: